Q: what is religious commandment of cursing to caliphs,because of extortion of right of Hazrat Ali (a.s.)?

A: the cursing is because of refusal of God's order and refusal of Holy Prophet's commandments disobedience is bothering of Almighty Allah and his Prophet, and whose bothering God and God's Prophet, are cursing in this world and after like. "this bothering God and his Prophet, God, keep away them his mercy in this world and after like and provide them the despiseable tortures." [Ahzab: 57]

But the bothering the holy Prophet has waste meaning and involving to every bothering him, such as atheism, disobedience of God's order, accusation and to cause inconvenience Prophet.

Sunni and Shia tradition accepted that bothering the Prophet Progeny especially Ali (a.s.) and Fatima (s.a.) is also the bothering God and his Prophet, according to legal entity of Hazrat Ali (a.s.) which mentioned in Holy Quran and in Prophet views, the extortion of the Ali's rights is also bothering Allah and his Prophet. The holy Prophet says: "Fatima is the part of my body, the one who makes her angry, makes me angry.

[Sahih Bokhary, chp. 5, p. 26]

And in another case He said: "Fatima is my part, the one who bothers her, bothers me.

[Sahih Moslem, vol. 4, p. 1903, chp. Fazail-ul-Fatima]

In the histories book mentioned, some other various cases that, they bothered the holy Prophet in his like and after like.

• 18/08/2009 23:03 - What is Ziyarat?

• 20/12/2008 16:38 - What are the reasons of nihilism?
• 20/12/2008 16:37 - What are the reasons of aberration? What must we do for the disbelievers?
• 20/12/2008 16:34 - To knowing God, first we should believe them to have reason, or vis versa?
• 20/12/2008 16:31 - If all Divine religious are truth, why we should obey Islam?